Frankfurt | Reuters — Bayer shares plunged as much as 14 per cent on Monday, losing about US$14 billion in value, after newly acquired Monsanto was ordered to pay US$289 million in damages in the first of possibly thousands of U.S. lawsuits over alleged links between a weedkiller and cancer.
After the verdict in favour of a California school groundskeeper with terminal cancer, Monsanto faces more than 5,000 similar lawsuits across the U.S. over claims it did not warn of the cancer risks of glyphosate-based herbicides, including its Roundup brand.
Monsanto, bought by Bayer this year for US$63 billion, said that it would appeal against the jury’s verdict in California, which is the latest episode in a long-running debate over claims that exposure to Roundup can cause cancer.
The case by plaintiff Dewayne Johnson, filed in 2016, was fast-tracked for trial due to the severity of his non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma, a cancer of the lymph system that he alleges was caused by Roundup and Ranger Pro, another Monsanto glyphosate herbicide.
“The jury’s verdict is at odds with the weight of scientific evidence, decades of real world experience and the conclusions of regulators around the world that all confirm glyphosate is safe and does not cause non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma,” Bayer said in a statement.
Having closed the Monsanto takeover, Bayer is only awaiting the approval of some final antitrust-related asset sales before folding it into its own organization. It did not negotiate any payments from Monsanto shareholders for Roundup-related litigation.
Bayer shares were down 11.2 per cent at 82.93 euros (C$124.16) at 1:20 p.m. GT, the worst performing stock on the Stoxx Europe 600 index , and on track to close at their lowest in almost five years.
Barclays analysts said Bayer was in for a “litigious headache.
“Whilst an appeal is certain and may indeed likely result in the penalty being moderated at a minimum if not reversed altogether, a large number of similar pending cases will now likely multiply.”
Berenberg analyst Alistair Campbell said resolving the issue could cost Bayer US$5 billion, citing a rough estimate based on a past product liability settlements such as Merck’s US$4.9 billion settlement over painkiller Vioxx or Bayer’s US$4.2 billion total settlement over the Baycol cholesterol drug.
The controversy could also affect future revenues.
Genetically modified (GM) crops that withstand glyphosate are a main source of cash for Monsanto, mainly generated in North and South America, where the technology is widely accepted.
The health worries could further darken the outlook for a product category following the emergence of weeds that have grown resistant to the herbicide.
“We think the risk of withdrawal is extremely low, but if it materialized it would be a major blow to the transaction value paid for the company,” said Berenberg’s Campbell.
Discovered by the Monsanto chemist John E. Franz in 1970, patent-free glyphosate herbicides are now sold by the global crop protection industry despite the dispute over its safety.
The U.S. court ruling caught many Bayer investors off guard as no hard evidence of a causal link to cancer had been produced so far.
The World Health Organization’s (WHO) cancer arm in 2015 classified glyphosate as “probably carcinogenic to humans”, but the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency in September 2017 concluded a decades-long assessment of glyphosate risks and found the chemical was not likely carcinogenic to humans.
A Reuters report in October showed that the WHO’s cancer agency dismissed and edited findings from a draft of its review of glyphosate that were at odds with its final conclusion that the chemical probably causes cancer.
In Europe, the EU Commission in December drew criticism for renewing the licence for glyphosate. Germany and France have meanwhile taken steps to phase out use of the herbicide.
The U.S. case may prompt some retailers to curb sales of Roundup products. Homebase, one of Britain’s largest home and garden improvement retailers, is reviewing the sale of glyphosate-containing products in the light of the jury’s decision, a spokeswoman said.
Glyphosate-exposed stocks also plunged in Asia and particularly in Australia where a withering drought has already hit herbicide sales.
Australian chemical maker Nufarm, which Macquarie Bank analysts estimate earns about a fifth of its revenue from glyphosate-based products, plunged almost 17 per cent to a more than two-year low.
Its top shareholder, Japan’s Sumitomo Chemical, shed three per cent, while Australian rural services firm Elders, which retails herbicides, fell 11 per cent.
— Reporting for Reuters by Ludwig Burger; additional reporting by Tom Westbrook in Sydney, Ben Hirschler in London and Yuka Obayashi in Tokyo.Tagged appeal, Bayer, cancer, glyphosate, lawsuits, monsanto, shares